To get ahead you have to stay informed.

AUTO

When’s the Best Time to Refinance Your Car Loan?

EXPECTED READ TIME: 8 MINUTES

Soon after the excitement of driving your new or used vehicle begins to fade, you might start dreaming about the day you no longer have to make monthly payments on it. As PenFed's Sr. Director of Auto Lending Product Strategy, Stephanie Roberts has spent more than a decade helping members find the auto financing option that actually fits their situation, refinancing included.

While refinancing your car loan soon after the purchase date won’t get you out of paying for the car, it might speed up your loan payoff and lead to substantial savings on interest over time.

Read on for insights to determine if refinancing your vehicle early is the right avenue for you.

Key Findings

  • The timing of an auto refinance can depend on when the vehicle title and lien information are finalized after purchase. In some cases, this process may take several weeks or longer.
  • Refinancing may be worth considering if your credit profile has improved, market rates have changed, or you want to adjust your monthly payment or remaining loan term.
  • A lower interest rate or different loan term may reduce your borrowing costs, but it is important to consider any applicable fees, prepayment penalties, your remaining balance, and the vehicle's value before refinancing.

What’s Auto Loan Refinancing?

Auto loan refinancing is when you borrow money to pay off your existing car loan and replace it with a new one. Refinancing has become a popular and fairly easy way to improve your financial situation by restructuring one of the most common types of debt.

Icon money

Learn the difference between good and bad debt.

How Soon Can You Refinance Your Car Loan?

Although you can technically refinance as soon as you find a lender willing to approve you for a new loan, the benefits really depend on timing. Let’s look at what it means to pay off your loan early, depending on how long you’ve owned your car:

60-90 Days Into Your Loan

Most credit unions and banks require the title to be in hand before they’ll refinance a car loan, so waiting a few months will give you more lenders to choose from and increase your chances of being approved. That’s because, whether you buy a new or used vehicle, it usually takes two to three months for the car title to transfer from the auto manufacturer or previous owner to your lender.

Auto loan refinancing is when you borrow money to pay off your existing car loan and replace it with a new one.

Two or More Years Left on Your Loan

Believe it or not, you can wait too long to take out a new auto loan. Some lenders require you to have two or more years left on your original loan to qualify for refinancing. Others are reluctant to refinance cars that are more than 10 years old or have over 140,000 miles.

car icon

Trying to decide between a new or used car? Read our guide.

It's also worth noting that if you postpone refinancing for years on end, you won't save as much in interest. Lenders typically front-load loans with interest charges, so the more months you make payments on your original loan, the more interest you're actually paying.

What Documents Do You Need to Refinance a Car Loan?

Documentation requirements vary by lender, but you may be asked to provide:

  • Government-issued ID
  • Proof of income (recent pay stubs or tax returns)
  • Proof of residence
  • Proof of auto insurance
  • Vehicle registration
  • Current loan details

Having the necessary documents available before you apply may help streamline the application and loan-processing process.

How Soon Can You Get Approved for a Car Refinance?

The time required to process an auto refinance application can vary based on the lender, your application, and factors such as income verification and the vehicle's title status.

Having your financial and vehicle information available when you apply may help avoid unnecessary delays.

PenFed allows eligible consumers to check potential auto refinance offers through pre-qualification without affecting their credit score. A formal application may require a hard credit inquiry and is subject to credit approval and other eligibility requirements. 

Why Should You Refinance Your Car Loan Early?

If you’re thinking about refinancing your car loan when you haven’t been making payments on the vehicle for very long, it should be to do one (or more) of four things:

  1. Lower your interest rate
  2. Reduce your monthly payment
  3. Shorten your repayment period
  4. Extend your loan term

The ultimate goal should be to pay less in interest charges, and by extension, save cash over the duration of your loan.

Some lenders require you to have two or more years left on your original loan to qualify for refinancing.

Of course, you need to determine if any potential savings are worth your time and effort before you commit to refinancing. Use an auto refinance calculator to crunch numbers and see how different loan amounts, interest rates, and terms will affect your payments.

As a member-owned, not-for-profit credit union, PenFed can often offer more flexibility on rate and terms than a bank or a dealership's captive lender which is a difference worth weighing before you refinance anywhere else.

Advantages of Refinancing Your Car Loan Early

When conditions are right, greenlighting a refi within a year or two of when you took out your original auto loan offers a number of benefits. Here’s a snapshot.

The ultimate goal should be to pay less in interest charges, and by extension, save cash over the duration of your loan.

Lower Interest Rate

If interest rates have fallen or your credit has improved since you financed your car or truck, it’s probably worth your time to at least explore refinancing. The money you stand to save by locking in a lower rate sooner rather than later could be substantial.

Smaller Monthly Payments

There are two ways you can reduce your monthly car payment when refinancing: get a better interest rate or extend the length of the loan. If you can make the numbers work, the first option is far and away the best because you’ll save money both in the short and long term.

Calculator Icon

Curious about how a refi might affect your monthly payment?

Faster Loan Payoff

Depending on the amount you still owe on your vehicle and the interest rate you’re able to secure, refinancing to a shorter-term loan can either raise or lower your monthly payment. One thing that’s certain, however, is that you’ll pay less interest charges over the life of the loan.

Improved Financial Situation

Although refinancing to a longer-term car loan is less ideal than shortening your term length, it makes sense if you can’t afford your current monthly payments. You’ll pay more in interest in the long run, but it’s better than defaulting on your loan.

There are two ways you can reduce your monthly car payment: get a better interest rate or extend the length of the loan.

Disadvantages of Refinancing Your Car Loan Early

Refinancing your car loan isn’t without its potential bumps in the road. Here are several hazards to watch for and avoid.

Prepayment Penalties and Fees

If you’re thinking about refinancing, first confirm whether your loan carries prepayment penalties. Depending on your original lender, you may be charged a prepayment penalty if you refinance because you’re technically paying off your original car loan before its term ends.

If you’re thinking about refinancing, first confirm whether your loan carries prepayment penalties.

The additional charge could potentially cost more than the amount you stand to save with a new loan, or they may be worth it in the end, but you don’t want to get all the way through a refi application to be hit with surprise recalculation.

On top of early payment penalties, you may also have to pay lender fees, closing costs, and title transfer fees if you refinance your loan. Fortunately, these one-time add-ons typically cost less than $100 combined.

On top of early payment penalties, you may also have to pay lender fees, closing costs, and title transfer fees.

Additional Interest Charges

If you refinance to a longer-term loan in order to reduce your monthly payment, you’ll likely pay more in total interest over the life of the contract. How so? Interest accumulates over time, so adding months to the term length increases the amount you eventually shell out.

Upside Down Value

One of the biggest risks of refinancing is owing more on your vehicle than it’s worth. Known as being upside down in your loan, you’re on the hook for the full amount of your new loan until it’s paid in full — even if your car is totaled in an accident or rendered useless some other way.

certificate icon

Here’s everything you need to know about car titles.

This can happen if you refinance repeatedly. Before you refinance more than once, learn how often you can refinance a car and when it may stop paying off. Since cars depreciate over time, taking out a new loan over and over may extend your financial burden to the point where your car depreciates below what you owe.

Lower Credit Score

When you apply to refinance your auto loan, it triggers a hard inquiry on your credit report, which decreases your credit score temporarily. Being late with your payment or missing one altogether because you can’t afford your new loan can do longer-term damage to your credit.

The dip is usually smaller and shorter-lived than many borrowers expect. FICO and VantageScore both use rate-shopping windows that treat multiple auto-loan inquiries made within a short span (typically 14 to 45 days, depending on the scoring model) as a single inquiry for scoring purposes, so comparing offers from several lenders shouldn't cost more than one hard pull.

Refinancing repeatedly over months or years, rather than during one rate-shopping window, is what compounds the credit-score impact, according to Experian's guidance on auto loan refinancing.

AdvantagesDisadvantages
Lowers your interest rateMay trigger prepayment penalties and fees
Reduces your monthly paymentCould increase overall interest charges
Speeds loan payoffMight put you upside down in your loan
Improves your ability to make paymentsDecreases your credit score temporarily

How Much Could Refinancing Actually Save You?

Here's a real example.

Say your original auto loan is $25,000 for 60 months at 6.04%, with no down payment or trade-in, which works out to a payment of about $484 a month.

A year in, you're carrying roughly a $23,400 balance with 48 months left to go.

Plug that same 48 months into a new loan at 3.49%, and the monthly payment actually ticks up slightly, to about $523 a month. What matters more is the interest you pay over the life of the loan: at 3.49%, you'd pay about $1,873 less in total interest across those 48 months than you would sticking with the original 6.04% rate.

That's the tradeoff worth understanding before you refinance: a lower rate can raise your monthly payment and still leave you ahead if it cuts down the total interest you're paying.

Is Refinancing Right for You?

Just because you can speed forward with an auto loan refinance doesn’t mean you should. There are times when it makes sense to accelerate a refi and other times when you’re better off hitting the brakes.

When It Makes Sense

Generally speaking, it makes sense to shift into high gear on refinancing your auto loan when:

  • Your credit score has improved, making you eligible for a better rate
  • You find a lower interest rate and better terms than what you currently have
  • You can afford to shorten the loan term, leading to savings over the life of the loan
  • You can save more money than any potential costs you may have to refinance
  • You’re struggling to make your payments and need to reduce your monthly bill

PenFed Credit Union members can check their auto loan refinance options and get prequalified with no impact to their credit score.

If you postpone refinancing for years on end, you won’t save as much in interest.

When It Doesn’t Make Sense

Even though refinancing has its upside, it may not be the best route to take if:

  • You have less than a year to pay off your original loan
  • Your vehicle has lost significant value over time
  • You can’t get a lower interest rate than you currently have
  • You owe more on your loan than the car is worth
  • You’re not able to improve your financial situation in some way

Frequently Asked Questions

In most cases, you can refinance as soon as 60 to 90 days after buying your car. Lenders typically need the vehicle title in hand before approving a refinance, and title transfers usually take two to three months to process after purchase.

There's no universal waiting period, but most credit unions and banks want two to three months for the original lender to finish transferring the title. Waiting also gives your credit score time to reflect post-purchase improvements, which can help you qualify for a better rate.

Refinancing can cause a small, temporary dip in your credit score because the lender runs a hard inquiry. Multiple hard inquiries within a short window are often counted as one for scoring purposes, and timely payments on the new loan typically offset the dip within a few months.

The 2% rule is a rule of thumb some lenders and financial sites use, suggesting refinancing is worth considering when the new rate is at least two percentage points lower than your current rate. It's a starting point, not a guarantee of savings, since fees and remaining loan term matter too.

Refinancing is generally worth it when you can secure a lower interest rate, reduce your monthly payment, or shorten your loan term without paying more in fees than you'd save. It's less worth it if you're close to paying off the loan or owe more than the car is worth.

Technically yes, if a lender approves you, but most credit unions and banks won't process a refinance until the original lender finishes transferring the car's title, which typically takes 60 to 90 days after purchase. Refinancing sooner rarely helps, since your payment history is still too short to improve your rate.

The Takeaway

Refinancing your auto loan when the time is right may help you save money in the short or long term and put you on the fast track to paying off your vehicle.

By weighing the pros and cons and taking an honest look at your personal situation, you can determine if swapping out your old auto loan with a new one will help improve your financial well-being and enhance the overall enjoyment of your ride.

PenFed Credit Union members can check their refinance options and get prequalified with no impact to their credit score.

Find Out More About Car Loan Options Through PenFed

Discover the diverse offering of products, services, and support available to our members.