April 16, 2021
To put it simply, debt is stressful. It weighs on you. No one likes to owe money, but for many Americans, taking on debt is the only way to get by.
Whether you're struggling with credit card debt, student debt, or other types, we'll explain what it means to consolidate, what the different options are, the potential advantages and disadvantages, and more.
What is Debt Consolidation?
Debt consolidation is combining multiple debts into a single debt, usually by way of a new loan. This allows you to make one monthly payment for all of your debts. The goals of any form of debt consolidation are to lower the amount of interest you pay on your debt and, ideally, reduce your monthly payments.
Pursuing debt consolidation is helpful for those strapped with several high-interest debts, such as credit cards, a car loan, and student loans.
How Does Debt Consolidation Work?
There are different ways to consolidate debt. For example, most credit unions, banks, and other lenders offer debt consolidation loans, credit card balance transfers, and more. Or you can find not-for-profit debt management companies or credit counseling agencies that offer debt management plans.
Here's an example of how debt consolidation works. Let's say you're carrying a balance on two credit cards, each with an interest rate of 16.00% APR, plus a student loan with an interest rate of 8.00% APR.
Instead of making three monthly payments, you can consolidate those three debts into one single debt. This could be done by taking out a debt consolidation loan and using that borrowed money to pay off the balances of your credit cards and student loan. Then you will make monthly payments toward your debt consolidation loan until the loan term ends.
When consolidating debt, you want to find a loan or plan with a lower interest rate than what you originally had across your debts. This may help reduce your monthly payment. You also want to make sure you don't get a longer term than what you already had, to avoid paying more in interest over time.
Once you're approved for a new loan or enrolled in a debt management plan, you can begin making your monthly payments until all of your debts are paid down.
Run your numbers through a debt consolidation calculator to find out how much you may be able to save.
Debt Consolidation Options
There are several ways to go about debt consolidation, but the most common types include a debt consolidation personal loan, debt management plan, balance transfer, or student loan program.
Debt Consolidation Personal Loan
With a personal loan (secured or unsecured), you receive the borrowed money in one lump sum with a fixed interest rate.
While personal loans typically have lower interest rates than credit cards, you need good credit to qualify for a low rate. When you apply for a consolidation loan, the lender assesses your repayment history, credit scores, and other factors to determine whether you're likely to be able to pay back your loan. The bottom line, you have to be creditworthy to get approved for a debt consolidation loan.
Take a closer look at debt consolidation loans.
Credit Card Balance Transfer
Many credit card companies or credit unions offer balance transfers, which allow you to transfer your existing card balances to a new card with low or no interest.
Here are a few factors to consider:
- A 0% annual percentage rate (APR) typically has a limited time frame of 12-18 months. After that, standard interest rates may apply if you still have a balance.
- You may have to pay a transfer fee of 2-5%. This fee is added to your balance.
- You need a very good to excellent credit score to qualify.
This method will align best with your goals if you plan on paying off your balance before the 0% introductory APR period ends.
Find the right credit card for you.
But since these options require you to borrow against the equity in your home, not paying the loan back could result in the lender foreclosing on your home.
Get more information about home equity.
Student Loan Program
For the 44.7 million Americans with student loan debt, there are ways to consolidate student loans.
You can consolidate federal loans through the federal government with options such as the Federal Direct Loan Program. You may also be able to consolidate your student loans through your credit union, bank, or a specialized student loan lender.
Debt Management Plan
A debt management plan is a way to consolidate without getting an additional loan. A debt management company or credit counseling agency will combine your debts into one monthly payment and coordinate with your creditors to negotiate a lower interest rate.
You'll then make your payments to the company or agency, which will allocate your money to your creditors. The end goal is for you to pay down your debt in 3-5 years.
Here are a few factors to consider:
- Debt management plans don't base eligibility on credit scores, so this may be a good option for borrowers with lower credit scores.
- While the plan itself may not directly impact your credit score, your participation will be noted on your credit report, which may indirectly and temporarily impact your credit score.
- There may be set-up or maintenance fees but watch out for unnecessary application or membership fees.
Provided by not-for-profit companies, these programs often include credit counseling and education programs to help you improve your money habits.
Benefits of Debt Consolidation
Depending on your financial situation and which approach you choose, debt consolidation could have several potential benefits.
For example, if your consolidation loan has a lower interest rate than your original loan, you'll end up with a lower monthly payment amount. Or if you select a shorter term when you consolidate, you could pay off your loan faster.
Other benefits include one monthly payment instead of several, and the ability to choose a fixed rate so you never have to worry about rate hikes.
Drawbacks of Debt Consolidation
The main drawback is that consolidating to a higher interest rate or a longer term than your original loan could cause you to pay more in interest over time. But it depends on your loan terms.
Plus, whenever you're talking about a loan, you also have to be aware of the potential fees: balance transfer fees, closing costs, prepayment penalties, or loan origination fees.
Something to also remember is debt consolidation won't prevent you from going back into debt — you have to be willing to change your financial habits.
When Debt Consolidation Makes Sense
Consolidating debt depends on your financial situation. You may be ready to explore debt consolidation if:
- You're having trouble keeping up with your monthly payments
- You're paying down debt on five or more credit cards
- You've maxed out your credit cards or are close to your credit limit
- You have a high enough credit score to qualify for a lower loan rate
- You're willing to change your spending habits, meaning you won't rack up more debt
When Debt Consolidation Does Not Make Sense
While consolidation has many advantages, it might not be your best choice if:
- You have a small amount of debt
- You're considering student loan forgiveness
- You need to improve your credit score because you likely won't qualify for a lower interest rate
- You don't intend to change your financial habits, which means you could wind up back in debt
How Debt Consolidation Affects Your Credit
Applying for any loan results in a hard credit inquiry, which can temporarily lower your credit score by up to five points. A debt management plan isn't a loan, so doesn't require a hard credit inquiry, but it may indirectly impact your credit score.
But making on-time payments and not adding more debt can improve your credit score over time.
|Debt Consolidation Method||Credit Check||Impact on Credit Score|
|Personal Loan||Hard credit inquiry||Temporarily lowers credit score|
|Home Equity Loan/HELOC||Hard credit inquiry||Temporarily lowers credit score|
|Student Loan Program||Hard credit inquiry||Temporarily lowers credit score|
|Credit Card Balance Transfer||Hard credit inquiry||Temporarily lowers credit score|
|Debt Management Plan||Eligibility not based on credit score||May indirectly and temporarily impact your credit score|
Your Next Steps
As you consider your consolidation options, think about these key points:
- Credit: Is your credit in good standing? Will you qualify for a new loan with a better interest rate than what you already have?
- Financial behavior: Debt consolidation works best when you don't take on any more debt as you pay down your existing debt. Is that feasible for you?
- Timeframe: A debt consolidation plan or loan payoff may take 3-5 years.
With the right approach for you, debt consolidation may help you work toward eliminating your debt — and that financial stress.
Explore a Debt Consolidation Loan
Get a closer look at how consolidating could help you.