September 22, 2023
Buying a car or truck can make a big dent in your budget.
To keep yourself on firm financial ground in case of the unexpected, you may want to consider Guaranteed Asset Protection (GAP) insurance and an extended warranty for your vehicle.
Let's take a look at these optional protection plans and how they can help you save money.
What Is GAP Insurance?
GAP insurance is supplemental car insurance that bridges the “gap” between the amount your standard comprehensive and collision insurance will cover if your vehicle is stolen or totaled in an accident and the balance you have remaining on your auto loan or lease. Optional GAP coverage may be purchased at the same time you buy or lease a new car at the dealership or through a finance company. If you did not elect coverage at the time of purchase, some finance companies will allow the coverage to be added for a period time after the loan is established.
How Does GAP Insurance Work?
If your car is stolen or deemed a total loss following a wreck, your insurance plan will typically pay actual cash value (ACV), minus your deductible, to replace it. ACV is the amount the insurance company determines someone would reasonably pay for your car if the theft or accident had never occurred. Actual cash value takes into account:
- Wear and tear
- Mechanical problems
- Cosmetic condition
- Supply and demand
How Much Does GAP Insurance Cost?
settlement you receive from your insurer might not be enough to replace your car with an equivalent vehicle and pay off the remainder of your original loan or lease. This could leave you stuck making payments on a vehicle that you don’t have or can no longer drive. That’s where GAP insurance comes in.
Everything seems fine until you receive a check for $19,500 — the amount of the settlement minus your $500 deductible. That’s when you realize you’ll have to shell out $5,500 of your own money to pay off your loan balance. And you’ll still be without a car to drive.
Once you’ve paid down the loan to the point where the car is worth more than you owe, you should remove the GAP coverage.
If you had been carrying GAP insurance on the vehicle, it would have given you an additional $5,000 more. (GAP policies do not cover your insurance deductible.) You’d still have to make arrangements to buy a new ride to get back on the road, but at least you wouldn’t be paying off a totaled car.
Keep in mind that most GAP coverages have a loan-to-value (LTV) maximum and will only cover to the LTV maximum limit of their coverage.
According to the Consumer Protection Financial Bureau, “loan-to-value ratio (LTV) is the total dollar value of your loan divided by the actual cash value (ACV) of your vehicle.” To put this in perspective, typically, when you make a down payment, you’re bringing down the LTV. That’s a good thing when it comes to GAP insurance — the lower your LTV, the better chance you have for full coverage.
Maximum LTV limits can vary, so you’ll have to check with your specific provider.
What Does GAP Insurance Actually Cover?
Cars depreciate quickly, with new cars losing up to 40% of their value in the first year. This depreciation means the actual cash value of your car could be less than what you owe on it.
If your car is totaled or stolen, your insurance company will give you the car’s ACV, or actual cash value. That’s what the car is worth after depreciation. But the ACV may not be enough to finish paying off your auto loan. GAP insurance covers the amount you lost through depreciation.
Cars depreciate quickly, with new cars losing up to 40% of their value in the first year.
PenFed members qualify for GAP advantage — an additional $1,000 toward a new vehicle when you finance that vehicle through PenFed.
What Does GAP Insurance Not Include?
GAP insurance is not the same as regular car insurance. It pays out a specific amount in a few, limited circumstances. It does not cover:
Interest that accrues on your car loan after the date you lost your vehicle
Costs that were added to your loan balance after you purchased your GAP policy, such as extended warranty or other vehicle add-ons
Routine vehicle maintenance or repairs
Balances you rolled into your auto loan, such as the balance on your previous car
Upgrades you made to the car since purchasing it
Security deposits on leases
Financial penalties for violating your lease agreement (like overuse or excessive mileage penalties)
Difficulty making payments on your auto loan or lease agreement
Vehicles with titles such as salvage, rebuilt, lemon, or buyback
Keep in mind, most GAP insurance policies do not cover your auto insurance deductible.
GAP insurance only provides the difference between what you paid for your car and its value at the time of loss.
When Does GAP Insurance Not Pay?
There are cases when GAP insurance will not pay out, including when:
A car is damaged but not totaled (meaning the cost of repairs are less than the value of the car)
A car needs routine maintenance or repairs
A vehicle is used for commercial purposes
GAP insurance also doesn’t cover:
A rental car after an accident
Damage caused to other people’s property
Lost wages or medical expenses resulting from an accident
Missed car payments
It’s important to understand that GAP insurance alone will not fully cover the cost of a new car. GAP insurance only provides the difference between what you paid for your car and its value at the time of loss. You’ll need to file a claim with your regular car insurance company as well to receive enough money to full replace your car.
How Much Does GAP Insurance Cost?
GAP insurance is usually sold at a one-time cost. Typical GAP policies cost between $400 and $700 when wrapped into your loan by the dealer, and between $20 and $40 per year if you add it to your auto insurance policy. For instance, you can purchase GAP insurance from PenFed for $449 by adding it to your auto loan. The cost of GAP insurance will vary some based on four main factors:
Your vehicle’s actual cash value (ACV)
The age of your vehicle
Your auto insurance claims history
Is GAP Insurance Worth the Money?
GAP insurance generally makes a lot of sense if you:
Finance your vehicle with less than 20% down
Put a lot of miles on your vehicle, which decreases its value more quickly
Purchase a luxury car or SUV — they depreciate faster than less expensive vehicles
Extend your loan beyond 60 months to keep your payments lower
Trade in a car and roll the balance of the old loan into the new auto loan
GAP coverage is also a good idea — in some instances, even a requirement — if you lease rather than buy a car or truck. That’s because the market value of the vehicle would likely be lower than the amount still owed on the contract if the car was stolen or totaled during the lease period.
If you opt for GAP insurance, you probably don’t need to carry it the entire time you have the vehicle.
If you opt for GAP insurance, you probably don’t need to carry it the entire time you have the vehicle. Ideally, once you’ve paid down the loan to the point where the car is worth more than you owe, you should remove the GAP coverage. GAP insurance wouldn’t pay any additional reimbursement if the car was stolen or totaled.
Keep in mind, some GAP coverages are not refundable. For example, some plans will not allow you to remove the coverage after 60 days. That said, many providers offer a “free look” period during which you can add GAP and cancel before the end of the period for a full refund.
Pros and Cons of GAP Insurance
As with most optional items you can select for a new car or truck, there are a number of pros and cons to carrying GAP coverage on your vehicle.
|Pros of GAP Coverage||Cons of GAP Coverage|
|Pays what your standard insurance doesn’t (some limits do apply)||Useless if vehicle was bought with cash or had a large down payment|
|Can be purchased from dealer, lender, or insurance company||Adds to overall cost of ownership|
|Relatively inexpensive if added to an auto policy||Often goes unused|
Getting GAP Coverage
How to Buy GAP Insurance
You can add GAP insurance to an existing auto insurance policy, but you can also purchase it separately through a different provider such as a bank or credit union.
Most dealerships will offer you GAP insurance while you’re negotiating financing, but they must wait two days before actually selling you the policy. This is to keep buyers from feeling pressured into policies before they can research alternatives.
When to Buy GAP Insurance
Most insurance companies won’t sell GAP insurance for a car that’s more than two or three years old. They may also set limitations on mileage if you’re purchasing a used car.
You’ll be eligible for the most coverage if you purchase GAP insurance sooner rather than later. For instance, most companies require you to purchase your policy within 180 days of purchasing your car to qualify for Return to Invoice or Vehicle Replacement insurance. (Return to Invoice gives you the value of your vehicle listed on your invoice, while Vehicle Replacement gives you the amount it would cost to buy a brand-new version of your vehicle.)
Optional GAP coverage must be purchased at the same time as you buy or lease a new car, and you must be the vehicle’s first owner or leaseholder.
Where to Buy GAP Insurance
You can buy gap insurance from banks, credit unions, or any company that sells auto insurance. These are usually the cheapest options, costing between 5% and 7% of the comprehensive and collision premiums on average.
Car dealerships sell GAP insurance, too, but their policies are usually more expensive, running between $400 and $900. Policies usually get rolled into your financing, which means you’re paying interest on your policy as well as monthly premiums.
FAQs About GAP
Is GAP Insurance Required?
GAP insurance is not required when you buy a car but is often required when you lease one. Many dealers include GAP insurance in your lease or financing agreement, and you may see a fee for it included with your other fees.
How Do I Know I Have GAP Insurance?
You can check your current car insurance policy or the terms of your lease or loan to see if you have GAP insurance.
Do I Need GAP Insurance if I Have Full Coverage?
Most companies require that you have comprehensive and collision coverage to qualify for GAP insurance.
GAP insurance is important if you still owe money on your car lease or loan. Full coverage will only cover the value of your car at the time you lost it, which may not be enough to replace your car. GAP insurance will cover the depreciation from the time you purchased your car to the time you lost your car.
Can I Get GAP Insurance on a Used Car
It’s possible to get GAP insurance on a used car although some insurers require a car to be under three years old to qualify. If your car is too old to qualify, you might consider loan and lease payoff or new car replacement plans.
Is GAP Insurance Refundable?
Whether your GAP insurance is refundable or not depends on the company providing your GAP insurance. Many companies will offer you a partial refund if you cancel your policy within a certain time frame, but that timeframe varies from company to company. PenFed’s policy are nonrefundable after 60 days.
GAP insurance is designed to cover expensive car repair costs and ultimately save you money, but it isn’t for everyone and every situation.
Before purchasing any type of insurance take an honest look at your financial situation and consider how much risk you’re willing to take. Then, you can decide and ride with confidence, knowing that you’ve done all you can to protect yourself and your auto investment for years to come.